Name: Pappagallos Pizzeria & Mediterranean Restaurant
Price range: $$

Pappagallos Pizzeria & Mediterranean Restaurant Information

Stepping into Pappagallos Pizzeria & Mediterranean Restaurant on Raritan Avenue, you immediately get a sense that this spot balances classic Italian comfort with Mediterranean flair. The menu here is a delightful mix, from wood-fired pizzas with perfectly crisp crusts to hearty Mediterranean entrees that bring bold flavors to every bite. The pizza offerings range from traditional Margherita to inventive combinations featuring fresh herbs, tangy cheeses, and locally sourced vegetables, all baked to order with that signature golden-brown crust. On the Mediterranean side, dishes like chicken shawarma, lamb gyros, and fresh tabbouleh showcase a thoughtful balance of spices, textures, and freshness that keep patrons coming back.

Service at Pappagallos feels both warm and attentive without being overbearing, creating a friendly neighborhood vibe that matches the casual yet inviting decor. Diners often note that the staff is quick to offer recommendations, whether you’re debating between a classic pizza or a Mediterranean specialty. Portion sizes are generous, making it a great choice for sharing plates with friends or family, and the presentation never feels rushed or sloppy. The interior is cozy with a mix of communal tables and smaller booths, offering an approachable atmosphere for both casual lunches and relaxed dinners.

Reviews consistently highlight the consistency and quality of the food. Customers appreciate that even on busy nights, each dish maintains its freshness and flavor, from the perfectly seasoned hummus to the robust, savory notes of the pizza toppings. The restaurant’s location in Highland Park makes it an accessible stop for both local residents and visitors exploring the area, with a convenient spot for takeout or a relaxed dine-in experience. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick slice, indulging in a Mediterranean feast, or pairing a pizza with a glass of wine, the menu here provides satisfying options for a variety of cravings.

Beyond the food, Pappagallos Pizzeria & Mediterranean Restaurant also impresses with its attention to detail-crispy yet tender pizza bases, flavorful sauces, and fresh ingredients all contribute to a sense that care is taken in every dish. For those who enjoy vibrant flavors, hearty portions, and a friendly neighborhood ambiance, this Highland Park gem delivers an experience that’s both comforting and memorable.

What People's Say About Place

If you're anywhere near this gem you must go dine in!!! The food is absolutely amazing and the service with Adam superb. As we ate our appetizers we knew we made the right choice. My coworker is from Kentucky and I'm from Knoxville, TN. You can guarantee if I'm ever in this area again I promise I'll be back. We had the mozzarella sticks, salad and bread as an appetizer. This already had my mouth watering as we waited for our main dish. I had the Fettuccine Alfred with grilled chicken. My coworker had the Chicken Marsala. The portions are very large and worth every cent. I highly recommend you check them out!!!

What a great place! I came with my husband tonight & sat outside and the ambiance was so relaxing. The inside was so clean and felt so homey. We were recommended the Penne Vodka with chicken and the Chicken Parmigiana with spaghetti. So delicious ! The Tres Leche dessert was so rich and the carrot cake was so moist definitely coming back for more.

New place great reviews so me and my sister went to check it out. It really holds up to the reviews, amazing service & amazing food. -Pizza- we had the Margherita pizza. Sauce was sweet tangy and fresh, I personally wish there was more basil. I can just imagine how good the calzone here is by that pizza. This pizza is very addictive, it’s been a few hours and I’m still craving that pizza no matter how full I am -With our orders we had a side salad with bread & balsamic vinegar. Honestly, the sauce was amazing like everything, the attention to detail here is just awesome, warm bread came with garlic oil that was just prefect -Linguini With Clams (white sauce): this was my sisters order, she wished it was saltier but when I tasted it, it was nice and very buttery. - Grill Salmon Special- I loved how lemony this dish was and how everything just works together. Very generous with portions and the size of the salmon. I love how simple this dish is and how delicious it is. Desserts- very sweet They didn’t have Tiramisu when we went but the tres leche cake was still amazing. Very creamy and sweet. The frosting I believe had a bit of cream cheese that helps cut the sweetness but still very sweet. Second dessert I believe it’s the Baklava, very flakey, honestly would be prefect as a breakfast dessert. It was a bit too sweet for my liking but I loved how flakey it is. Would 100% recommend people to try here, I need another bite of that pizza

I found this place by just looking up “pizza shops near me” and boy am I glad to have done so. Their white pizza that I got with extra garlic was delicious, the mozzarella sticks also fantastic and to top it off I called to tell them the food was fantastic and the owner hand delivered a free desert to me. It was carrot cake and it was also amazing. You really can’t get better service and food for the price. Highly recommend and my roommates and I will be ordering again for sure!!

Omg this place is amazing. Adam was so sweet and kind. Now this food is just delicious. I highly recommend you visit. I am from Kentucky and my co worker is from Tennessee. The portion size was unbelievable. If Im ever in this area again I will be back!

Pappagallos has become our full time pizza spot. The menu offers all sorts of pizza options from Big Mac to chicken vodka. We love the cheesesteak pappagallos and any of the soups. The salads are made fresh to order and you can choose a protein to add. Nice outdoor seating right on Raritan. We feel just like family when we visit.

I love this place so much! My husband and I come here for all of our dates because we love the food and we love Adam !! He’s the absolute best he’s so welcoming and friendly and treats us like family! Going there this week haha !

Great place to stop and dine-in. The food is served like a real Italian dine in rather then a cheesy pizzeria The food was great, it was super clean and the owner is very friendly as his staff is also. First time here. FOUR STARS (I don’t believe in perfection)